Compelo Energy is using cookies

We use them to give you the best experience. If you continue using our website, we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on this website.

ContinueLearn More
Close
Dismiss

Table 4, Qualitative comparison of the environmental performance of a linked-basins TPP at Fundys Shepody Bay (HB) and Cumberland Basin(LB), vis–vis the chosen standard of comparison, a single-basin, DE-TPP, Type Z, at Fundys Cumberland Basin. The tabulation shows which of the two types scores highest for optimum environmental performance.

NOTE:Re D, Sea-mammal survival: TPPs should be designed and operated to keep sea mammals away from the hydraulic turbines. This applies equally to both linked-Bs and Type Z and therefore does not affect a comparison between them.
DE = double-effect; SE = single effect; HB = high-basin; LB = low-basin Linked-Bs = linked-basins

Environmental effects A B C E F
Type of TPP Linked-basins, SE, Fundy (HB and LB) Single Basin, DE at Fundy (LB)
TPP parameters
Mean, natural tidal range 10.m 10m
Mean tidal range within high basin as % of natural tide 34 % 68 % Z Z Z
Mean tidal range within low basin as % of natural tide 36% 68% Z Z Z
Mean water level within high basin, compared to natural conditions +2.9m -0.12m Z Z
Mean water level within low basin. compared to natural conditions -2.6 m -0.12m Z Linked-Bs
Number of passes through turbines, for a fish going in-and-out of TPP 1 2 Linked-Bs
Plant operation at or close to the rhythm of the natural tide no yes Z
Maximum head across turbines 6.96m 4.62m Z
Maximum water velocities through turbines 15.6m/sec 11.9m/sec Z
Stagnant flow within high basin % of the time 42% 18% Z
Stagnant flow within low basin.% of the time 42% 18% Z
Simplicity of flow patterns See Fig. 5 Z
Total scores for Iinked-Bs, SE-TPP 0 0 1 1 0
Total scores for Type Z (DE) plant 5 4 2 1 3